I find myself enjoying watching [boxing] whenever I have the opportunity. Organising a discursive essay A set of weighing scales There are two basic types of discursive essay. He obviously has an agenda or position on his focus topic, and he is quite persuasive, but he also does a great job outlining arguments for and against and then settles on his own position, which he makes clear by the end. Ultimately, we came to an agreement that the form is super flexible, but there are some elements that students can use to guide them. This point has been convincingly argued by journalist Charlotte Leslie in The Guardian. It is a way of challenging yourself. Email required Address never made public.
Here are my notes: There are many examples of boys from underprivileged backgrounds who, instead of becoming involved in street fights and gang warfare, have found a more worthwhile outlet for their instincts through boxing. This thesis presents an interpretation of a literary text or texts. When looking in the library, focus on the non-fiction and reference sections. To show that the writer is an expert on the subject.
There are many connectives and they often work well after a semicolon as this creates a useful ‘pause and emphasis effect’.
It proves that boxing is dangerous and should be banned. In the Seoul Olympics some years ago an element of hooliganism caused chaos during exampls after the fights, leading to the President of the Olympic Games forecasting the biteslze would eventually be forced out of the Games.
I am constantly on the lookout for discursive texts as my students have had very limited exposure to this text type and need a lot of examples to clarify their thinking and build their understanding and appreciation.
Example Imagine the following article has appeared in your local paper: It is an example of how the writer justifies violence.
This will allow you to check it again later and to complete your bibliography and footnotes. To many, it seems inconsistent to condemn violence in society and at the same time allow a sport which glorifies it. It is unlike a discussion essay in that it does not need to be formal or objective in tone, however, it can have formal and objective aspects. In paragraph four the writer states that “in the Seoul Olympics an element of hooliganism caused chaos ringside during and after the fights.
Discursive texts can be humorous or serious in tone and can have a formal or informal register. Bianca and Kate thanks so much for this work in furthering what esday obviously continue to be an ongoing discussion of these issues.
Another great source is the annual collection of the Best Australian Essays which sadly stopped being published last year, but which I am sure you can still get from Black Inc Books. Which of the following three justifications for boxing does the writer consider the most important? Here are my notes:. If done well, they can also make the contrasts clear between the two sides in favour of your view. There are many examples of boys from underprivileged backgrounds who, instead of becoming involved in street fights and gang warfare, have found a more worthwhile outlet for their instincts through boxing.
What the heck is a ‘discursive text’?
Or can someone point me to the literary or genre theory that those terms are drawn from? I am a big fan of The Conversation, as a lot of their pieces are quite balanced in their approach to the focus topics, discursige yet they both engage and inform their readers. There is no doubt that boxing is a very violent activity which polarises opinions, with prominent members of the medical profession strongly condemning the sport while boxing fans are equally passionate in supporting it.
You can see from the example how the use of a connective can help the argument to flow smoothly and seemingly logically: To show that the writer is an expert on the subject. They may have failed in other areas and have come to see themselves as dropouts from society.
discursivd What is the function of the opening sentence of paragraph two – “I am certainly aware of all the powerful arguments against boxing”? Boxing matches are conducted under established rules and procedures and bitesiez a referee, judges and timekeeper. An effective argument presents different viewpoints. Some boxers even claim some kind of divine inspiration.
You know how HSC English now requires students to write discursive essays as well as persuasive and imaginative… would you say Orwell writes discursive essays?
Writing to persuade, argue and advise – Revision 1 – KS3 English – BBC Bitesize
I have seen young boxers turn from outcasts to role models. So, when I am confused and seeking clarity and wisdom, what do I do? This is a rhetorical question. This thesis presents an interpretation of a literary text or texts.
When you are writing an argument, it is important to start with a plan which starts with a list of views both for and against the topic. Also, I disagree with what it says about traditional analytical essays for English being persuasive, that is just plain confusing for students.
They create a fluent and logical structure that helps to suggest fairness and balance.